The Smuggler's Tide

I know who did it
CASE NO. 64 · LEVEL 2 · SMUGGLING

THE SMUGGLER'S
TIDE

CLUE
1
OF 6
SCAN TO ANSWER
In the fishing village of Porthcove, customs found 120 fake designer watches hidden in lobster pots in Smugglers' Cove. A boat landed them during the night. Find all 6 clues, compare the statements and the evidence, and work out who did it.
Ruth Kane
Customs officer
”The pots are painted ‘JP’ – Joe Penhale's mark. But anybody can borrow a lobster pot. The boat that landed them left marks in the sand.”
WITNESS STATEMENT · RUTH KANE
EVIDENCE #1 · SCENE REPORT
Customs report – Smugglers' Cove, Thursday 06:00
Found
3 lobster pots marked ‘JP’, 120 fake watches
Keel mark
In the sand at the high-water line
On the rocks
Fresh scrape of blue boat paint
Footprints
Washed away by the falling tide
The boat landed while the tide was in.
1
2
3
4
5
6
Find all 6 clues, then scan the code to name the culprit.
NEXT CLUE IS HIDDEN …
Read the clues as plain text
Clue 1 of 6

Ruth Kane Customs officer

”The pots are painted ‘JP’ – Joe Penhale's mark. But anybody can borrow a lobster pot. The boat that landed them left marks in the sand.”

Evidence #1 · SCENE REPORT

Customs report – Smugglers' Cove, Thursday 06:00
Found
3 lobster pots marked ‘JP’, 120 fake watches
Keel mark
In the sand at the high-water line
On the rocks
Fresh scrape of blue boat paint
Footprints
Washed away by the falling tide
The boat landed while the tide was in.
Clue 2 of 6

Joe Penhale Fisherman, boat ‘Kittiwake’

”Those are my pots, but they were stolen from the quay on Tuesday – the whole pub heard me moan about it. I went out at ten to four, same as every day.”

Evidence #2 · HARBOUR LOG

Porthcove harbour log · Wednesday night
BoatSkipperOutIn
MorwennaDan Hocking21:0023:05
Sea WrenAlice Trevor23:3002:10
KittiwakeJoe Penhale03:5009:00
Clue 3 of 6

Dan Hocking Fisherman, boat ‘Morwenna’

”I was back in harbour by eleven and in Gary's pub until closing. Anyone who knows these waters knows you can't get into that cove whenever you like.”

Evidence #3 · TIDE TABLE

Tide table · Thursday
TideTimeHeight
High water01:405.1 m
Low water07:550.6 m
High water14:055.0 m
Smugglers' Cove: a boat can only land there up to 2 hours before or after high water.
Clue 4 of 6

Gary Rowe Pub landlord

”Dan sat at my bar from quarter past eleven until I locked up. And Joe never shut up about his stolen pots on Tuesday night.”

Evidence #4 · BAR TAB

THE ANCHOR INN
Tab: Dan Hocking
23:15 Pint of bitter
23:50 Pie and chips
00:30 Pint of bitter
Closed 00:58 – doors locked
Clue 5 of 6

Beth Lowry Lighthouse keeper

”I write down every boat I see from the lamp room. The cove is east of the point, about twenty minutes by boat.”

Evidence #5 · LIGHTHOUSE LOG

Porthcove lighthouse · Watch log
TimeSeen
23:40Sea Wren – lights by the point
00:30Sea Wren – lights by the point
01:15Sea Wren – lights moving east
01:55Sea Wren – back by the point
04:00Kittiwake – heading west
Clue 6 of 6

Alice Trevor Fisherman, boat ‘Sea Wren’

”I was squid fishing off the point from midnight until two. My lights never left the point – Beth can tell you. And I don't sell watches; I just sell jewellery.”

Evidence #6 · BOAT REGISTER

Porthcove boat register
BoatHull colourOwner's other work
KittiwakeRedNone
MorwennaGreenBoat repairs
Sea WrenBlueMarket stall – watches & jewellery